Skip to main content

Council votes 6-to-1 for tax hike

April 2, 2012

WOONSOCKET — Despite an outpouring of protest, the City Council voted in favor of a 13 percent supplemental tax hike for 2011 that will cost homeowners and businesses hundreds of dollars, all in hopes of keeping the teetering city from going broke in the days ahead.
Although they had not done so as of press time, councilors were also expected to approve a companion measure that will allow the city to borrow up to $6.6 million against the anticipated collateral of the new tax receipts to bring a sorely needed infusion of cash into the city’s coffers. Judging from the rate of returns on supplemental tax bills in Central Falls, city officials guess they’ll collect 65 percent of the supplemental levy at best, or about $4.3 million. Bills are due by June 15.
But the city isn’t out of the water. The emergency tax is just one prong of Mayor Leo T. Fontaine’s plan to pull the city from the brink, but he still hasn’t secured another key element, a 10 percent wage concession from all city employees for the balance of the fiscal year. Without those concessions, state officials say some sort of financial intervention for the city is likely, perhaps the appointment of a budget commission with the power to take control of budget decisions.
“I want to take this opportunity to ask you to work hard, harder than you ever have,” Councilman Daniel Gendron said. “We need to put this together, and put this together fast.”
More than 100 residents attended the session in Harris Hall, a far cry from the turnout for a public hearing last week. While many continued to express strong opposition to the supplemental tax bill, there was a note a resignation in the voices of many who approached the lectern in Harris Hall.
Some, like Alethia Forcier, urged the council to explore future reforms that spread the tax burden around more fairly.
In a refrain heard again and again, Forcier said roughly a quarter of the city’s property-owning residents are footing the bill for all the rest.
“We’re hitting the same people over and over and over again,” said Forcier. “It has to be fair. These 10,000 people cannot support the whole city of Woonsocket…I think everybody knows we need to change the dynamic in the city. We just need someone with the gall to do it.”
Larry Fitzsimmons, a member of the Woonsocket Taxpayers Coalition, echoed those sentiments, saying the city needs to find another solution to its budget problems than raising taxes. The city floated a $90 million pension bond not long ago, but it has one of the most underfunded local pension systems in the state; it borrowed another $12 million last year to erase prior deficits, yet another nearly as large has ballooned within the School Department.
“The people of Woonsocket have been paying their fair share and more,” he said. “The effort to eliminate deficits in the city is not working. Taxing the people additionally won’t solve this problem because it’s not caused by lack of revenue.”
The frustration over the runaway costs of running the schools was often bluntly framed as a case of too few working people underwriting services for the poor.
As Brian Tanney put it, “It’s time to send the freeloaders packing and put up a sign that says Woonsocket is open for business.” The crowd reacted to his comments with a brisk round of cheers.
In supporting the measure, councilors said they disliked the idea of supplemental tax bills, but the alternatives of a budget commission or bankruptcy were even less palatable.
For Councilman Christopher Beauchamp, it is the likely loss of the city’s homestead exemption that frightens him most. Yes, said Beauchamp, the supplemental tax bill will probably be devastating to some residents, possibly forcing them to lose their homes. But a receiver would surely eliminate the generous homestead exemption and cause much more widespread pain.
“I you do the math and the receiver came in and took away a portion of that homestead exemption, it would be a much greater hit than the 13 percent, and I can’t afford that,” he said. “I thought bankruptcy was a great idea and then there’s conflicting information. I’m teetering, but I want to see what we can do first as opposed to somebody mandating what we have to do. We have a little more time to fight back.”
Another supporter, Councilman Albert G. Brien agreed, saying the council must do everything it can to keep the city afloat, or the city would surely face worse economic devastation.
“I’d love to have the luxury of not being able to support this legislation,” he said. “It’s either going to be a haircut, as Judge Flanders (the receiver in Central Falls) says, or it’s going to be a beheading.”
The only opponent was Councilman Roger Jalette, who championed state intervention as a way of forcing the city to solve the underlying financial problem that local leaders do not have the stomach for.
The vote sets the supplemental tax rate for residential property at $3.13 per thousand, which means the owner of a home worth $100,000 will pay another $313. The rate for business and commercial property is $4.51 per thousand; motor vehicles and trailers, $5.81. The combined revenue raised by the increases means the actual tax increase for 2011 was a whopping 17.16 percent.
It’s all part of Fontaine’s multi-faceted plan for stop the city from going broke this month after the discovery of a $10 million deficit in the School Department’s budget. In addition to supplemental taxes and a bank loan, Fontaine is negotiating with six city employees’ unions for a 10 percent pay cut for the balance of the fiscal year. As of last night, Fontaine said the unions are still not on board.
“Unfortunately, it’s not the sole answer,” Fontaine said of the supplemental bill. “And there’s no guarantee we won’t go into receivership. If the unions don’t come forward with concessions, that becomes a fail-point in this process.”
Many city officials have pointed the finger of blame for the crisis at former School Department Business Manager Stacey Busby and former Supt. Robert Gerardi. Some say Gerardi went on an unwarranted hiring binge before he took a new job last year, while Busby was fired last week for forecasting a small surplus in late 2011 before independent auditors discovered the staggering deficit.
Members of the School Committee opted against a criminal probe of the ex-school personnel last week, but now that very panel may be in the crosshairs of political annihilation. In a move spearheaded by Council President John F. Ward, the council also proposes to let voters decide whether the school committee should be seated by appointment instead of election.
The Charter Review Commission recommended the council adopt a similar proposal in 2011, but the council passed on the offer. Amid a new round of questions about accountability and oversight in the education department, the council appeared poised to approve a measure to resurrect the proposal, which would put it on the agenda for the Nov. 6 ballot.
If approved at the ballot box, the five members of the School Committee would no longer be seated by voters. Instead, the mayor – however it is – would appoint the chairperson of the school committee. The remaining four members would be appointed by a search panel seated by the mayor.
And the council isn’t apparently ready to let go of the notion that someone should be held criminally responsible for the financial debacle in the education department. In a rebuke to the School Committee’s 3-2 vote against a criminal probe last week, members of the City Council voted to initiate an inquiry into the matter.
Councilman Marc Dubois, who was chairman of the School Committee when the panel granted Busby was a controversial contract that made it difficult for her to be fired for any reason, declined to answer questions posed to him by a spectactor last night, on the advice of City Solicitor Joseph Carroll. Since he may be subpoenaed and asked to testify under oath about Busby’s contract, Carroll said he should not make any comment on the probe and recuse himself from voting on the measure to launch the inquiry.
But Dubois said he supports the probe and wants it to go forward.
“I was disappointed in the School Committee’s vote,” he said.
The panel was also expected to approve a plan to use its powers under the City Charter to query investigative targets and other potential witnesses under oath, summoning them to appear before the panel by subpoena. It’s happened previously as recently as 2008, when Fontaine, then council president, launched a probe into alleged misappropriation of funds in the former administration of Mayor Susan D. Menard. She challenged the council’s authority in court and managed to stifle probe into oblivion, though the courts eventually upheld the council’s authority to stage such an inquiry.
The last time the council may have initiated such an inquiry in earnest was in the early 1990s, when members questioned a former police chief in connection with the 1982 murder of Doreen C. Picard. The council was looking into allegations of a police coverup in the bludgeoning death of the 22-year-old from Bellingham. Raymond “Beaver” Tempest Jr., the son of a former Woonsocket police commander and former high sheriff for Providence County, is serving 85 years at the ACI for the crime.
The council has no powers to lodge a criminal complaint against anyone. But if it uncovers what it believes is probable cause of a crime, it can turn over its findings to the state police.

Comments

I'm done with the Psychopaths!

April 5, 2012 by t_cote (not verified), 2 years 23 weeks ago
Comment: 1100

Oh my God! Where do I begin......

Robert Hare wrote 2 great books; (1) Without Conscience, and (2) Snakes in Suites.....2 of the best reads if you live in the State of Rhode Island! Just unbelievable!

Free services in Woonsocket.

April 4, 2012 by MrFister (not verified), 2 years 23 weeks ago
Comment: 1096

My familiy and I are excited about relocating to Woonsocket!

How do we go about getting those free services I heard so much about?

Just what can we get, anyway?

Thanks, in advance.

poor little Woonsocket....

April 3, 2012 by cuk (not verified), 2 years 23 weeks ago
Comment: 1085

It would be difficult not to feel Susan Menard didn't have knowledge of this unbelievable situation...she had such a tight hand on every aspect of 'controlling' this city. Shouldn't she be questioned as to how this could have happened? Perhaps take some responsibility...all of this mess was brewing on her watch!!

CVS

April 3, 2012 by Marcel (not verified), 2 years 23 weeks ago
Comment: 1083

We all better hope the likes of CVS and other corporations located in the city don't do what Walmart did by packing up and leaving for friendlier territory.

I'm totally bummed at what's becoming of Woonsocket.... I was gone for 20 years, came back on a visit in 2001 and was totally amazed at how much things had improved. People were raving at how Mayor Menard took the city through this transformation. Businesses were humming, place looked great and the condos were coming to old delapidated buildings, now full of tax payers.

I guess all good things come to an end sooner or later. Even Walmart has come and gone.... I don't know of anyhwhere else in the country where Walmart bailed on a city where it was located.
At least this tax increase won't immediately affect those who live on welfare or government assitance... Soon there will be more joining these ranks.

Thanks for nothing......

April 3, 2012 by Marcel (not verified), 2 years 23 weeks ago
Comment: 1081

My wife and I own a condo and a waehouse that we were attempting to convert into a duplex, uplifting a building that I'm sure affects the value of the homes near it.
The supplemental bill puts us over the top. That empty building is taxed as commercial, so between that place and our condo, we'll be hit a whopping $900-$1000 extra with this new charge to us from the city.
We will now pay more for taxes on a 1400 sf condo than we do for a 2100sf home in Southern California where we weekly have a street sweeper go by, sidewalks maintained by the city and a well staffed police department. Orange County CA also went through bankruptcy over five years ago and we're now golden. We never saw a supplemental tax bill as cost for services was trimmed to the bone and the county recovered.
I also feel terrible for those running a business or owning rental property in Woonsocket. They'll have to pass on the increase to their custoners and renters. I wonder if Fair Housing is going to allow a higher rent be paid for section 8 tennants. Afterall, renters use city services and all citizens should pay for this problem we are facing.
Central Falls collected 65% of the supplemental tax bill. If this goes the same for Woonsocket, a small number of people will be paying for this short fall. This will mean more to come in the future with regards to supplemental tax bills.

Council votes 6-to-1 for tax hike

April 3, 2012 by vaz185 (not verified), 2 years 23 weeks ago
Comment: 1079

Hello Mayor The state of Rhode Island just won a 265 million dollar Google Law suite why cant we used $10 million dollars from that money to help Woonsocket out instead of coming after the tax payers we don't have the money? Do you hear me PLEASE! How about CVS instead of them donate to charity why cant they donate to there home town? Thank you

city council

April 3, 2012 by cmj (not verified), 2 years 23 weeks ago
Comment: 1078

Just know that since you didn't want to listen to what the residents of this city who voted for you, had to say & what we want, then come election time I will not vote for any one of you nor will I vote for any of the present school committee members!!!! You can all rot in hell you idiots!!!!!!!!!!!! I hope every single one of you has to claim bankruptcy down the road & lose everything you have!!!!!

Council votes 6-to-1 for tax hike

April 3, 2012 by vaz185 (not verified), 2 years 23 weeks ago
Comment: 1077

Hello I live here all my life and owned many houses in Woonsocket every time you turn around they are raising something all I am trying to do is make a honest living here,just cant do it anymore in woonsocket. The water & sewer bills are though the roof and now they want to kill us with another tax bill. The dam city officials cause these problems! There the one that bankrupt the city not the tax payer! Now they are trying to bankrupt the tax payer! Do you understand English We don't have the money to pay for your mistake HELLO! No matter what I say will not change anything cause they just don't care what the people have to say! I am tired of fighting they are all no good crooks! They have force me & middle and high class right out of this city! I am selling everything & moving. All my houses are in mint condition very well care for & up keep Tthey have lost another good home owner! I hope the Bums enjoy the city!

What a Tangled Web We Weave !

April 3, 2012 by Jeffo46 (not verified), 2 years 23 weeks ago
Comment: 1075

Raisng taxes is not the solution here . All it's going to do is make more people move out. We need to cut the spending and to make concessions starting with the Mayor and the City Council. I haven't heard any mention of them offering to take a cut in pay in their salaries, have you ? If they care as much as they profess to then maybe they should practice what they preach and start taking a pay cut. As far as those who are out of work, don't blame them. Blame the politicians in Washington who allow companies to move overseas to china, etc. thus allowing them to hire labor at a lower cost and keeping Americans out of work. That's why you have a huge percentage of people unemplyed today and collecting unemployment, welfare, assistance, etc. There is one thing that I do think should be in place for these people who are collecting though and that is they should be made to under go mandatory drug testing on a infrequent basis if they want to keep on collecting. Now back to the city's financial situation, please reconsider the supplemental tax increase because all you're going to do is,loose a lot of people by doing so. Also, a criminal investigation does need to be launched into the city and school department's financial situation, but by the federal government, not the state police. Just something to think about.

WOONSOCKET – Like a two-minute offense, life has moved fast lately for Brian Bouley and the...
DURHAM, N.C. -- For the second time in three years, the Pawtucket Red Sox are Governors’...
CUMBERLAND – If not for Cumberland High’s success in Division II over the past few...
BLACKSTONE – A crime-scene cleaning company is expected to finish its work today removing biohazardous material from a...
WOONSOCKET – Age is one thing, ability another. That’s what the owners of two school bus companies and a local police...
VIDEO: Week 2 preview: Patriots at Vikings The Boston Globe's Shalise Manza Young takes a look at the Patriots' Week 2...

 

Premium Drupal Themes by Adaptivethemes